Labour motion calls out legality of Minister of Health’s staffing restrictions and for Budget shortfall to be addressed

15 November 2026

Labour motion calls out legality of Minister of Health’s staffing restrictions and for Budget shortfall to be addressed - The Labour Party

The Labour Party has tabled a motion calling on Government to urgently address the growing budgeting crisis in the health service, properly fund the services being delivered in 2026 and reverse the restrictions on recruitment across HSE regions.

The motion will be debated next Wednesday at 10am.

Speaking in advance of the motion, Labour health spokesperson Marie Sherlock TD said:

“For too long Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil have persistently presented health budgets that they know are inadequate to meet the cost of existing services.

“The evidence from the Parliamentary Budget Office, the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, the HSE itself and the Government’s own spending outturns makes that abundantly clear.

“We are now facing the prospect of a health service recording a deficit in excess of €1 billion, with serious consequences for frontline services, healthcare workers and patients.

“Already we have staff and management in our hospitals blowing the whistle, calling out a dearth of resources to properly and safely staff our hospitals and provide the patient care needed. All of this before the flu season fully hits.

“Meanwhile we have a Government that continues to bury its head in the sand. The Taoiseach misleading the Dail when questioned on the crisis in CUH; plans to ease overcrowding in UHL shelved; all of which comes at a cost to those who need care most.

“The danger is that the cost of this year’s shortfall will simply be carried into 2027, eating into next year’s allocation before a single new service can be delivered.

“That is not responsible budgeting, it’s a failure to grasp basic economics, and we need to hear directly from Minister Harris, Minister Chambers and Minister Carroll MacNeill on how or if they are committed to properly plan for, budget and fund our health service.

“Labour’s motion calls on Government to present a Supplementary Estimate for the health vote that meets the actual cost of delivering health services in 2026, including the cost of maternity leave.

“Indeed it beggars belief that such is the level of disorder and chaos across the service that maternity leaves are not being accounted for and funded properly.

“It is essential to ensure that the 2027 health budget is not further undermined by a deficit arising from inadequate funding this year. However if Government continues on this course, that is the vista we are facing.

“Healthcare workers should not be made to pay the price for failures in Government budgeting and financial planning. Nor should patients face longer waiting lists and reduced access to care because the Minister and this Government has failed to provide the resources necessary to deliver existing services.

“We cannot keep budgeting for a health service that exists only on a Departmental spreadsheet. We need to have an honest and a real conversation about how we’ve funded one of the most vital public services in our country.

“Patients and healthcare workers deserve a health budget based on reality, not wishful thinking. This motion is an opportunity for the Government to acknowledge the scale of the problem and take responsibility for properly funding the health service.”

Motion re: Health Budget and recruitment restrictions

That Dáil Éireann

condemns:

  • the repeated presentation to Dáil Éireann of annual Estimates for Health which, on the evidence of the PBO, the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council, the HSE and the Government’s own outturns, the Government must know to be inadequate to maintain existing services;

notes:

  • the doubtful legal basis for the Department of Health taking operational control of recruitment decisions for health regions in Tier 3 financial escalation;

calls for:

  • the Government to reverse the systematic underfunding of the HSE by the Department of Health in 2026, by presenting a Supplementary Estimate for the Health Vote that provides for the cost of the services delivered in 2026 and specifically covers maternity leave, ensuring that the 2027 allocation and future services are not impacted, and cut further, by the 2026 deficit.

Marie Sherlock, Ciarán Ahern, Ivana Bacik, Alan Kelly, Eoghan Kenny, George Lawlor, Ged Nash, Robert O’Donoghue, Conor Sheehan, Duncan Smith, Mark Wall.

Stay up to date

Receive our latest updates in your inbox.
By subscribing you agree to receive emails about campaigns, policies, appeals & opportunities to get involved. Privacy Policy

Follow us

Connect with us on social media